URBANDALE,
Iowa - The Iowa Soybean Association has partnered with
Iowa Central Community College, Decker Truck Line Inc., Caterpillar
Inc., the National Biodiesel Board and the USDA to conduct a
unique field documentation study dubbed the “Two Million
Mile Haul.” This is a comprehensive study to examine the
benefits of a 20 percent soy biodiesel blend (B20) in an over-the-road
trucking company. Iowa Central is responsible for collecting
and analyzing engine performance data as well as periodic in-house
testing of the petroleum and B20 blend fuels for purity and consistency.
Additionally, the study examines the effects of various fuel
additives on the cold-flow properties of biodiesel blended with
the new 2007 Ultra-Low Sulfur Diesel (ULSD). The studies are
focusing primarily on the cloud, plug and pour points.
Summary of Results
As of April 2007, Decker logged more than half a million miles in the study using
10 trucks in the control group (fueled with 100 percent #2 petroleum diesel)
and
nine trucks in the B20 test group (fueled with 20 percent biodiesel, 80 percent
petroleum diesel). It was found that driver-to-driver variability in fuel consumption
within each group is two to three times greater than the overall difference in
fuel consumption between the two groups. Results showed a slight decrease in
fuel efficiency in the B20 group through the winter driving season. Average fuel
consumption for the control group was 6.01 miles per gallon (mpg) while average
consumption for the B20 group was 5.80 mpg, or a 3.5 percent reduction. This
value is not statistically significant (p = 0.125).
Winter driving produced relatively few problems regarding cold-flow issues. Fuel
for both groups was treated with a commercial fuel additive and #1 diesel (40
percent blend) was used for a brief time during a severe cold snap. No drivers
experienced fuel gelling problems.
Conclusions
Researchers feel that the first quarter of the study has been a success.
They found no significant difference in fuel consumption between the two groups
and were able to get through the winter driving season without any major complications.
The study also found that the driver-to-driver variability is larger than the
slight difference in fuel efficiency observed to this point and an entire four-season
driving cycle should be completed before conclusions can be made on fuel efficiency.
Regarding cold-flow issues, there were no fuel gelling problems during the cold
snaps and the plugged filters that did occur were not related to fuel quality
as outlined by ASTM-D6751 standards.
For more information on the first quarter results of the Two Million Mile Haul,
visit www.iowacentral.com/mathscience/science/programs/biofuels/research_collaboration.htm.
|
|